Key Takeaways

  • A valid contract requires an offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity, and lawful purpose.
  • Contracts may be invalid if formed under fraud, mistake, duress, or illegality.
  • Courts also examine mutual intent, clarity of terms, and whether both parties truly consented.
  • Some agreements must be in writing to be enforceable, such as real estate contracts.
  • Competency is key: minors, bankrupt individuals, or mentally incapacitated persons often cannot bind themselves legally.
  • Understanding what makes a contract valid helps businesses prevent disputes and ensure enforceability.

The requisites of a valid contract are the elements or details it must possess in order to be enforceable under the law. Contracts are a normal part of the everyday business world, and they're agreements that are legally enforceable. All agreements are considered to be contracts as long as they are made with the requisites in place, such as freely consenting parties who are competent to form a legal contract, for legal purposes.

Unresolved Contract Disputes

Misunderstandings regarding contract law sometimes cause conflict between parties. These misunderstandings are the cause of many contract disputes that end up in court. In court, the judge decides whether there was a valid contract between the parties or not. Contracts exist between partners, vendors, and employees. However, business owners don't typically keep an attorney on retainer to review each contract encountered. Understanding the basic details that make a contract valid can help you avoid finding yourself in a legal dispute that escalates to the court.

Essential Parts of a Contract

For a contract to be valid, there must be several key factors. These include:

  • An offer: One party must make an offer. Without an offer, there can't be a contract. This rule has been in force since 1950 when the Contracts Act passed. An offer, an advertisement, and an option are not the same thing.
  • Two or more parties with the capacity to enter a contract: There has to be at least one party with the legal capacity to make the offer and another with the capacity to accept it before an enforceable contract can be formed.
  • Acceptance of the offer: The contract can't become legally binding before it has been accepted.
  • Consideration must be exchanged: Each party to the contract must give something of value for the agreement to be valid.

Lawful Purpose and Legality of Object

Even if a contract contains all other elements, it is not valid unless it serves a lawful purpose. Courts will not enforce agreements that involve illegal acts, go against public policy, or promote fraud. For example, a contract for the sale of prohibited substances or one requiring a party to commit a crime is void. Similarly, agreements that unreasonably restrict trade, such as overly broad non-compete clauses, may be struck down for violating public interest.

Offer and Acceptance

At the time of making an offer, the party hearing the offer must understand what is being asked for and offered. Acceptance must follow the offer after the party hearing the offer is clear on the terms and conditions. If the terms are still being negotiated, it can't be considered an acceptance of the offer, and there is no contract during the negotiation stage. The offer can be accepted by the second party in either written or oral form.

Mutual Consent and Meeting of the Minds

For a contract to be binding, both parties must mutually consent to its terms. This is often called the “meeting of the minds.” Consent must be free of misrepresentation, undue influence, or coercion. If one party was misled about a material fact or pressured into agreeing, courts may declare the contract invalid. To avoid disputes, parties should clearly document their intentions and ensure that all key terms are expressly agreed upon.

Reasons the Court Considers a Contract Invalid

Only very serious matters cause the court to treat a contract as invalid. Those reasons are:

  1. It was formed in error: It's rare for the court to rule a contract is invalid due to error. Errors are considered to be things like entering the contract by mistake, but the court's usual rule is buyer beware. These errors can include factual errors, legal errors, and personal errors. These types of contractual errors are difficult to prove.
  2. It was formed under the threat of violence: This is less challenging to prove to the court than errors, and the violence can be threatened, perceived, physical, or moral in nature. Also, the threat doesn't have to come from the other party in the contract. There just has to be violence that pushed the person into the contract.
  3. It's fraudulent: When one party lies to get the other party to enter into a contract, that's fraudulent, and it makes the agreement void.

Writing Requirements and the Statute of Frauds

Some contracts must be in writing to be legally enforceable. Under the Statute of Frauds, agreements such as those involving real estate sales, contracts lasting longer than one year, or promises to pay another’s debt generally require written documentation. While oral contracts can be valid, proving their terms in court is often difficult. Written agreements provide clear evidence of obligations and reduce the risk of disputes.

Consideration

Consideration is another important aspect of a valid contract. It's the price that one party pays to the other in exchange for whatever thing has been offered in the contract. The agreement isn't legally enforceable as a contract unless each party gives and receives something. This is a vital part of any contract in order for it to be enforceable.

Adequacy of Consideration

While courts rarely examine whether the exchange in a contract is economically fair, consideration must be real and have measurable value. A promise to perform an act one is already legally bound to do, or to provide a purely nominal exchange without substance, may not qualify as valid consideration. For example, selling a car for one dollar could raise questions about whether true consideration exists, especially if it appears to conceal fraud.

Capacity

The parties involved have to have the capacity to legally enter a contract. This applies to both legal and mental capacity. Almost everyone is able to enter into a binding contract, with the exceptions of:

  • Minors under a certain age
  • Mentally incapacitated people
  • Legally interdicted people, such as someone who has filed bankruptcy

Older minors, up till age 18, can enter contracts but can change their minds at will and legally walk away from the deals. When someone isn't able to enter into a contract, there are regulations about who may enter into a contract on their behalf.

Special Cases of Capacity

In addition to minors and mentally incapacitated individuals, other categories of people may face restrictions when contracting. For example:

  • Bankrupt individuals: Certain legal restrictions prevent them from entering specific financial contracts.
  • Foreign nationals: In some jurisdictions, they may need special permits to contract in regulated industries.
  • Corporate entities: Companies must act within their legal authority (ultra vires doctrine) or risk having contracts voided.

Courts also assess whether a party was under the influence of drugs, alcohol, or severe stress when contracting. If impairment is proven, the contract may not be enforceable.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What makes a contract valid in law?
    A valid contract must include an offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity, mutual consent, and a lawful purpose.
  2. Can an oral contract be legally binding?
    Yes, but some contracts (like real estate sales) must be in writing under the Statute of Frauds to be enforceable.
  3. What happens if a contract lacks consideration?
    Without consideration, a contract is generally unenforceable, as both parties must exchange something of value.
  4. Can a minor legally sign a contract?
    Minors may enter contracts, but they typically retain the right to void them before reaching adulthood.
  5. Why do courts invalidate some contracts?
    Courts may invalidate contracts for illegality, fraud, coercion, mistake, or because they violate public policy.

If you need help with what makes a contract valid, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.